You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

Vindicator ago

@Millennial_Falcon @Vindicator what's your side of this story?

@MommyLove, a user who is very concerned about parental rights and CPS removing kids from families and the connection this may have to child trafficking, made a post about "medical kidnap" but did not specify how it might be connected, which I asked her to do. The next morning, MF removed it because that did not happen.

MommyLove reposted it, adding one sentence of explanation, but no links supporting the connection. MF removed that post as well.

Then she became frustrated that mods were removing posts and the baby's life was in danger and made a third post ignoring the v/pizzagate submission rules about mods being suspect. MF removed that one as well. He also banned her for repeatedly disregarding the submission guidelines, as we do for anyone who refuses to respect them.

During this, MommyLove DMed me for explanations (I usually give an explanation in comments to try to help people learn how to submit in accord with our submission rules. MF does not have time to do so.) Being in a different time zone, it took me quite a while to get to all her comments and messages, adding to the frustration. When she DMed about the ban, I explained it was only temporary; we unbanned her a couple days later.

Meanwhile, MommyLove complained to Psychanaut, who then DMed me demanding I take action against MF:

Psychanaut > Vindicator | Sent: 7 days ago on 6/7/2017 8:59:27 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

Dear Vindicator and Voat/pizzagate,

I want to officially move to have Millennial Falcon removed as MOD.

You are a mod, it's your job to be the gate keeper for the rules.

Therefore, please inform me of the official channels needed to take to make a formal complaint against Millenial Falcon for abuse of power, harassment and arbitrary application of the rules in an abusive fashion, meant to control, harass and intimidate people on Voat.

I want an official channel by which I can lodge a formal complaint and I'll let the process work for itself, but I am formally requesting the proper process by which to file a formal complaint.

Please note that on June 7, 2017, Psychanaut on behalf of myself 5 additional Voat users who's identity I am protecting for now, have asked Vindicator to lodge a formal complaint against Millenial Falcon and request to enact the process by which this formal complaint can be lodged.

My reply:

Vindicator > Psychanaut | Sent: 5 days ago on 6/8/2017 9:30:18 PM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

Hi Psychanaut,

Thank you for the DM. In order to have MF removed, you will need to present a well-documented explanation of why you think this is necessary to the owners of v/pizzagate: Crensch, VictorSteinerDavion and kingkongwaswrong. They specifically chose Millennial_Falcon based on his contributions as a user and his commitment to research supported by linked sources, so you will need to convince them -- with documented evidence in the form of links to removed posts, comments, or screenshots of DM's -- that they are wrong.

Complaining about him without objectively documenting your argument will only make you look like one of the hundreds of trolls who have tried to have him removed since last December when he refused to leave their unsourced or off-topic posts on the board. Unlike most places on the internet, Voat is not a place you can expect manners, sensitivity to feelings, avoidance of offensive language or comments. Voat was founded as a forum for true freedom of speech -- and the sitewide community values offensive speech as a sign of that freedom. Many old school Voaters engage in it gratuitously.

As a result, disgruntled users with hurt feelings due to mod actions or comments that do not violate the Moderation Rules will not be taken seriously. Nor will angry users who do not make the effort to document any Moderation Rule violations they present. Not even if there are a lot of angry or hurt users. That is just the culture of Voat. If you venture outside of v/pizzagate and complain about offensive speech instead of bad arguments or false information, you'll promptly hear "Fuck your fee-fees. Evidence or get the fuck out."

Please note that on June 7, 2017, Psychanaut on behalf of myself 5 additional Voat users who's identity I am protecting for now, have asked Vindicator to lodge a formal complaint against Millenial Falcon

I have not seen evidence that MF has abused his power, harassed or abused users (he rarely comments), or arbitrarily removed posts. Consequently, I will not be making any formal complaints.

@Disappointed @Kevdude @Crensch @VictorSteinerDavion

Following my reply, I received numerous DMs from Psychanaut claiming I was harassing her:

Psychanaut > Vindicator | Sent: 5 days ago on 6/9/2017 10:28:19 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

With 7 Voaters preparing this complaint, and counting, we feel we'll have enough. Thank you.

Vindicator > Psychanaut | Sent: 4 days ago on 6/10/2017 5:54:40 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

I hope you heard what I said. You could have 600 Voaters with hurt feelings. It won't get you anywhere unless you can set your feelings aside and provide evidence and documentation.

Psychanaut > Vindicator | Sent: 4 days ago on 6/10/2017 10:05:20 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

Are you harassing me?

Vindicator > Psychanaut | Sent: 3 days ago on 6/11/2017 6:28:23 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

Only in your imagination. I have copies of every conversation we've had, since the day I saw your first Quora post and reached out to help you figure out how to use Voat. My history speaks for itself.

That was my last reply to her and yet...

Psychanaut > Vindicator | Sent: 4 days ago on 6/10/2017 10:11:48 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

Just bear in mind, anything you do to intimidate or harass me or anyone involved in this-will go into the documentation I am preparing. And I hope you can hear me saying that to you now. This isn't about me. This is about you guys.


Psychanaut > Vindicator | Sent: 3 days ago on 6/11/2017 7:03:05 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

So you are harassing me. Keep it up. You're good cop/bad cop routine with MF is about to end.


Psychanaut > Vindicator | Sent: 3 days ago on 6/11/2017 7:10:03 AM Process for Filing a formal complaint for abuse

Maybe you should stop messaging me since I've already told you you are harassing me. Any rational person would have stopped by now. Perhaps you should take a step back and not attempt to bother myself or anyone involved in this, since we don't trust you any longer and because you keep messaging me about this. No one needs you to message about this, unless you feel you are personally involved. Are you? Does this concern you? Would you like it to? If not, then what is it you actually think you're doing?

Unless this concerns you directly, then you're not involved-unless you keep bothering me and interject yourself into this formal complaint process, in which case, you're guilty of harassment of someone who is making a formal complaint.

Is that what you want?

Is that what you are trying to do?

If not, then there is no reason for you to message me.

I'm telling you right now, I feel harassed by you.

If you continue past this point, then you have done so after my telling you formally that I perceive you as harassing me.

VictorSteinerDavion ago

This issue is far beyond my will to entertain it now.

I'm a-ok to consider any complaints about any mods, but this it is becoming clear that this is less about improving moderation standards and is much more about fee-fees.

I've been DM'd by Psychanaut over the last week or so and at no time did they indicate they were in communication with anyone else about this.

Part of my communication has text like:

What I'm looking for are clear cases of a moderator using the position to act against the interest of the community. This would be things like removal of a specific pattern of information, removal of posts made by a user due to a grudge relevant to a different verse, deletions to create drama etc.

And I can see from your comments we are in alignment on what we consider moderator abuse.
So far I've not seen anything that show unambiguously that M_F is a rogue mod, and so far I've taken no action in any direction.
I'm still open to evidence being presented, but given the drama festival going on about this I'm leaning towards doing nothing.