@letsdothis1 (pizzagatemods)

submitted ago by Crensch

@kevdude @Vindicator @VictorSteinerDavion

Post in question

@Millennial_Falcon cited rule 3 for removal, so I'm going to operate as if that's the litmus test here.

All titles must adequately describe post content and must establish direct relevance to pizzagate.

All the title does is list 4 things, one being pizzagate. It insinuates a link, but does not say for sure, or how, or through what new source or info.

Still, possibly acceptable on its own merits if we take the insinuation into account.

EACH link in your post must include a description of content and how the link relates to the post

I rest my case.

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

ESOTERICshade ago

Should we have another rules discussion? Part of me thinks we should clear out mods and see what happens. A two week experiment? If it works clear the rules?

I actually think the rules are pretty good. I think its the interpreter of the rules that is the problem. The lead mod does not fit in. I think its that simple. If that does not solve it then maybe tinker with the rules? But the rules actually look decent to me. And to be honest with you I don't know if there are enough interested parties left in the sub to have a rules discussion that would be very meaningful, its that bad.

heygeorge ago

Do you know where to find other 'interested parties' and see if they'd be interested in coming back for a new rules/moderation discussion?

think- ago

I don't think the rules are a problem in general.

The only thing I'd like to be changed is that OPs should have some time to fix a post, instead of deleting a post and require reposting.

Reason for this:

Often posts already have many comments when a mod deletes and asks to fix and repost.

Comments won't show on a repost, and discussions get interrupted by requiring to repost, even if its a minor issue that needs to be fixed.

I'd suggest to give OPs 30 minutes or so to fix, shouldn't they do so, delete and ask for repost.

This, of course, depends on whether the mods have the time to look at a post again in the given time period, I'm aware of this.

@Vindicator @Millenial_Falcon @kevdude

heygeorge ago

I believe a new rules thread has been started.

Well said, I think you should essentially post this over there.

think- ago

Thank you, I will take a look and crosspost. Also, I will ping some PG people to join the discussion.