SearchVoatBot ago

This submission was linked from this v/ideasforvoat submission by @Crensch.

Posted automatically (#46885) by the SearchVoat.co Cross-Link Bot. You can suppress these notifications by appending a forward-slash(/) to your Voat link. More information here. (@argosciv: Click here to suppress your crosslink notifications from @Crensch)

Armpit_and_Ass ago

I think it's more practical to have block/blacklists. There's whole subs of total winners who sit around pinging random people all day every day.

SeanBox ago

how can we ping users that we don't regularly talk to without being on their whitelist?

argosciv ago

Establish rapport with them in public or private.

The whitelist would be disabled initially/by default, so it's unlikely that many users would enable it without reason to (eg: being ping spammed previously by Dial or people like him).

Diggernicks ago

I'd rather kill myself (or you if necessary)than ever PM anyone.

If you've got something to say to me do so publicly, I'll do likewise

Super secret inner circle jerks are lame

argosciv ago

You said:

I'd rather kill myself (or you if necessary)than ever PM anyone.

If you've got something to say to me do so publicly, I'll do likewise

In response to my comment where I said:

(Emphasis added)

Establish rapport with them in public or private.

SeanBox ago

I know this is currently a relatively small community but I have pinged people I don't know simply because of a comment chain they were involved in. If you don't know the person at all this would make it impossible to get their attention.

argosciv ago

I see your point.

Possible workaround as part of implementation:

  • User account setting - boolean - "Display ping whitelist status" (Checkbox toggle. If enabled, user's profile publicly states whether or not they currently have ping whitelist enabled. True by default.)

This would allow you to check if the user has whitelist enabled. If they do, you could pm a link to the comment you want them to see and ask if they're happy to whitelist you. If you were to then become a problem, they could simply take you off their whitelist and/or block you to prevent any further communication via pm.

DietCokehead1 ago

Too complicated. Makes more sense just to have a ping blacklist.

argosciv ago

The problem there, though, is a blacklist would do nothing to address the use of unknown alt accounts from creating a mess -- which, dial seems to have countless which have ages ranging from ~14days to months/years.

Blocking users already fulfills the role of a ping blacklist.

A ping whitelist would address the situation of unknown accounts coming along and making a mess which otherwise takes up the time of the user.

Dortex ago

Seems like a small problem almost nobody faces. It's a waste of time to do this.