Subverse Rules Feature (Beta 2) (voatdev)

submitted ago by PuttItOut

Subverse rules are a feature Voat is implementing to remove subjectivism from moderator actions such as comment and submission deletions as well as user bans. Currently a moderator simply has to provide a “reason” why they are performing such actions, and seeing that often times this reason is made up on the spot, we are not happy with this. Going forward when a moderator performs such actions they will be required to select a rule violation. This requirement will help to establish the validity of the action.

Rules can be created at a subverse level by a moderator and Voat has some basic global rules, both of which are available as a selection on these moderator action screens as well as all report dialogs (comment/submission reports).

Rules will also be used in all domain and user bans going forward.

This feature is now in beta on the preview site and any testing would be greatly appreciated.

What needs testing:

  1. Subverse Rule creation
  2. Reporting comment and submissions in a subverse (making sure they show up in the v/sub/about/reports page)
  3. Moderator user banning and unbanning (all this code has been changed)
  4. Moderator comment and submission deletions

Test site: https://preview.voat.co/

P.S. The Vote feature is nearly fully implemented on the preview site, meaning you can create them, vote on them, and then manually process them for full lifecycle testing. :)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

Dudicles ago

Thinking out loud here:

--What problem is this fixing?

--Is it necessary to enact more rules to fix the problem?

--What problem could this be creating?

--How does selecting a rule violation--opposed to typing a reason--eliminate a mod being subjective about banning?

--Mod rules can be added or removed subjectively by the mods, thus allowing for them to ban based on rules anyway.

--Why is it bad for a mod of a small, niche subverse to be subjective with whom they want to allow to post?

Grifter42 ago

Because this is SBBH and Kevdude trying to gain control of the few subverses that they don't already have complete control of.