You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

argosciv ago

Oh look.

Here we have yournewswire using the exact same photo to accuse Israel of harvesting organs from dead Syrians.

[https://yournewswire.com/israel-harvesting-organs-syrians/ | http://archive.is/AdQ8s]

Article from 'Hoax or Fact':

[https://www.hoaxorfact.com/crime/dead-bodies-of-hundreds-of-kidnapped-children-found-in-container-organs-removed-hoax.html | https://archive.is/DujYa]:

Note: The first section of this article presents the false claims and the photo used to support them; the same photo used in the article in this thread's main post and the alternate source shared by @shewhomustbeobeyed.

"NSFW" photos...

Dead Bodies of Hundreds of Kidnapped Children Found in Container, Organs Removed: Hoax

by Prashanth Damarla 1 year ago


Dead Bodies of Hundreds of Kidnapped Children Found in Container, Organs Removed

Story:

Tamil Nadu police found this bodies of children in one truck container , this children were kidnapped from different part of country , all their body parts were removed like kidney , eyes , hands ,ect,,,

Pls take care of your children and froward for awareness


Analysis:

A disturbing image showing dead bodies of few children lying on ground is shared widely on social media platforms like Facebook and WhatsApp with different stories attached to it. Some purport to show that Tamil Nadu police have found the bodies of children in one truck container, saying they were kidnapped from different parts of country and that all their body parts were removed. Others suggested that Thailand police found dead bodies of hundreds of Malaysian children in a container vehicle, with their organs harvested. Although the picture showing dead bodies of children is real, and the messages warned people to take care of their children, the claim as such is not a fact.

Not a Case of Kidnapping and Organ Harvesting

The picture has been doing rounds on social media and other image sharing platforms and the stories warning people of children kidnapping and organ harvesting have been reported by some uncredible websites online. However, if the group of children were killed in such disturbing manner, the incident would have easily made into news and become popular online. There’s no such report in mainstream news outlets in Thailand, Malaysia or Tamil Nadu.

Aftermath of a chemical attack during Syrian Civil War

Aftermath of a chemical attack during Syrian Civil War

Chemical Attack in Ghouta, Syria

The children seen in the picture are real and they are all dead, but the unfortunate incident is not any case of kidnapping and organ harvesting, it actually shows the aftermath of a chemical attack that occurred in Ghouta during the Syrian Civil War on 21 August 2013. As you can see in couple of other pictures, the bodies of children are intact and no signs of organ harvesting are visible. Two opposition-controlled areas in the suburbs around Damascus City (Syria) were struck by rockets containing the chemical nerve agent Sarin. The chemical attack was carried out also against civilians, including children, on a relatively large scale causing hundreds of deaths and mass casualties.

~

The chemical attack in Ghouta took place during regime of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, which was accused by Western powers and the Syrian opposition. Later in October 2013 Syria officially joined the United Nations Chemical Weapons Convention, destroying the stockpiles of chemical weapons gradually. So the stories claiming the picture shows dead bodies of hundreds of children kidnapped and their organs removed are hoaxes.

cc: @Vindicator @ben_matlock


https://voat.co/v/pizzagate/2679509/13583841:

That’s what we do here. Research. Proof. That’s what we need here.

/cough

project_uniquename ago

Be careful when fact checking news on Syria. The MSM keeps trying to use false flag attacks to drum up support for war.

I don't have time to look into this story, but if I did, I would start by looking into Eva Bartlett's and Vanessa Beeley's work - reporters who have been to Syria and spoken to Syrians. I might look at Caitlin Johnstone and Jimmy Dore, since they put some effort into fact checking the Syria story and cite Bartlett and Beeley as sources.

This article claims that there was no chemical attack in 2013. Some sources mention that workers who come to scenes after attacks do not dress as they should if chemicals were really used. As for the 2018 attack, I read somewhere that people died from asphyxiation from being trapped in a dust-filled tunnel, not from chemicals.

cc: @dtneslo

argosciv ago

And you felt the need to reply to me with this because...?

Couldn't possibly have anything to do with my pointing out the fake news and otherwise calling out bullshit elsewhere, right?

Oh look at that, you're just another lurker who uses alts and pretends to know who Q is. Go lick Amalek's bunghole while you give ES a reach-around.

project_uniquename ago

you're just another lurker who...pretends to know who Q is

I think you've got me confused with someone else. I haven't mentioned Q once here, and I only have one other post so you can verify this quickly.

Pizzalawyer ago

@project_uniquename: Thanks for your contribution and sorry for the obnoxious reception you received. There is no accounting for bad manners and vulgarity.

These hoaxes may be sinister and designed to trigger civil unrest or it may be well intentioned folks using crime scene photos to get a legitimate warning to the public.

project_uniquename ago

Thanks for defending me. I'm going back to lurking, but I will see you guys again soon.

project_uniquename ago

I replied to you because your post mentioned that there were chemical attacks in Syria.

I have no problem with both of us pointing out fake news. There is so much of it that it takes a lot of people to sort it out.

argosciv ago

I can see right through your charade, faggot.

You got Agent999 jerking off in the corner too?


cc: @Vindicator

See comments context and user's history.

Look at this prick trying to blend in, even copying the "cc:" trend I started.

Pizzalawyer ago

@Vindicator: does this forum really have to tolerate the terrible behavior like argociv here? We all hate rules and censorship but some folks go too far which can inhibit participation by a newcomer who is on the receiving end of such insults.

There is also the element of fairness here. It took me 30 minutes to find the source of the photo of the dead girl in the box and to make a series comments. It only takes 10 seconds to tell a colleague to fuck off. And we are all colleagues for better or worse.

Anyone who is a shill and sifting thru our posts will eventually come to the realization that child trafficking is real (unless they are subhuman). Now when a shill is also a perpetrator of sex offenses, the more accurate reporting we do, the more that perp should start getting nervous that he'll be uncovered sooner or later. Just saying.....

Vindicator ago

I agree with you, Pizzalawyer. Attacking other users especially with vitriol is not helpful on this subverse. Not sure what is going on here, as I am slogging through 103 notifications in the past 24 hours.

There are three options for terrible behavior in Comments:

  • Downvote
  • Block
  • Ask them to stop

I have asked @argosciv to stop. I cannot ban anyone for their commentary. I would be demodded; Voat has zero tolerance for that kind of moderation.

Pizzalawyer ago

ok, thanks for explanation. and yes i do downvote

Vindicator ago

yes i do downvote

Good man. Also, thank you for providing your intelligent contributions on so many threads. That goes a long way toward refocusing conversation on useful topics when things devolve into drama.

argosciv ago

The girl in the box is not what I questioned here.

It's the fake news being created by mixing it in with the photo of Syrians.

As for the person I'm being belligerent towards, it is not without reason - I keep track of a lot of things and when a 'newcomer' shows up trying to reply to me in what appears(to me) to be a suspicious manner, I bite back a little until I can be sure.

You can lob veiled threats at me all you like, sounds just like srayzie and her merry band, though - so no, you don't make me nervous at all because the accusations against me are baseless.

PS: I've already contacted Task Force Argus about the slander I'm being subjected to.

cc: @Vindicator @ben_matlock @Millennial_Falcon

Pizzalawyer ago

relieved to see you defend yourself without vicious or vulgar language, its much more effective, dont you think? I lurked for a long time before climbing on board. I wanted to be sure this was a worthy forum. Im sure I was not alone in this approach and if I was attacked on my first few excursions, i would have gone away to spend time on Kardashian news.

argosciv ago

relieved to see you defend yourself without vicious or vulgar language, its much more effective, dont you think?

Actually, no matter what I do here, srayzie, think- and Shizy continue to levy hysterical slander at me and organize mass-downvote brigading; it's only effective with people who are themselves, capable of maintaining composure.

I can be a prick or 'professional' per what the occasion calls for.

Shizy ago

@think- @srayzie

I'm mean seriously? He's talking about us but won't ping us?

think- ago

Yep. Talking behind our backs, and complaining about us in long PMs he spams @Vindicator's inbox with.

So we have: accusation of 'hysterical slander' and the insult that @srayzie is a 'retarded judeao-Christian cunt'.

Plus the accusation of downvoat brigading, which is ridiculous, I don't even know how others here voat.

But he sees himself as being able of 'composure' and 'professionalism'. Well.

srayzie ago

He said this before @Vindicator asked me, @Shizy, and @Argosciv for a truce. So this one comment I’ll let slide.

think- ago

That's up to you, srayz. xo

srayzie ago

Xo

srayzie ago

@Vindicator I’m hoping this happened before the truce.

Vindicator ago

Yes, I believe so.

argosciv ago

More or less, yes.

Assuming there is indeed a truce going forward.

@srayzie @think- @Shizy

srayzie ago

Ok so let’s all be nice to each other.

Let’s do it for our Country

@Vindicator @Shizy @Think-

argosciv ago

Alrighty then.

And yes, I'll be responding to @Crensch's thread shortly, too.

@Vindicator @Shizy @Think-

argosciv ago

relieved to see you defend yourself without vicious or vulgar language, its much more effective, dont you think?

Actually, no matter what I do here, srayzie, think- and Shizy continue to levy slander at me and organize mass-downvote brigading; it's only effective with people who are themselves, capable of maintaining composure.

I can be a prick or 'professional' per what the occasion calls for.

Vindicator ago

Argosciv, you're attacking people indisciminately. Take a break from Voat. Go outside. Walk it off.

argosciv ago

Take a break from Voat. Go outside. Walk it off.

Fine.

Argosciv, you're attacking people indisciminately.

Just like the indiscriminate attacks against me. Very much appreciate it if you can address that with me in reply to the last pm I sent you - in the mean time, I'll go ahead and get back to more important work.

project_uniquename ago

even copying the "cc:" trend I started.

You had a good idea, and I wanted to use it myself. I've seen others use it too. I'm going for a few hours, so you guys can sort this out while I'm gone.

Shizy ago

Not everyone here is a rude asshole like this guy. You are welcome here and it's always good to have as many people as possible looking into this stuff so stick around!

3141592653 ago

Is hoax or fact like snopes ?

argosciv ago

Take it as you will. By all means, check them out, but, it's plain as day that the photos are being recycled to drum up bullshit.

Or y'know, ignore the obvious - whatever suits you and those tugging on heart strings here in the comments.

3141592653 ago

Either way, what they're doing to millions of kids in Syria is being horrifying

dtneslo ago

Read my replies, I covered all that...Look at the girl in the box....she has rigour mortis and her left foot is clearly broken...that is clearly an SE Asian girl, not Syrian..perhaps that image is from a one-off crime scene...Im not sure...also the images of large amounts of children does not show the grey-blue tint that was evidenced in the Syria chem attacks nor is there rigour mortis...obviously ALL these pictures are evidence of crimes against children.....where, what kind and who is what I am interested in

argosciv ago

I know you did, I've read your replies. Not trying to give you a hard time, just sharing what I found via reverse-image-searching.