You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

The_Invincible_Moose ago

This thread title is very misleading, especially with the associated picture.

And the article is rubbish reporting. It claims that:

Philippines President Duterte Calls Out Vatican For Pedophilia & Gold Hoarding

There's nothing in the article or its sources quoting Duterte criticizing the Vatican for pedophilia. The article alleges that he said the following, probably referencing Leo X (1475 – 1521):

Catholicism is a sordid religion. It is about time to show you its history. Pope Leo was sired and even had sex with his child.

Then they even admit that they are reading into Duterte's statement:

While the pedophilia statement could be argued, what can’t be argued is that fact that the Vatican has paid out over $4 billion dollars to victims of sexual abuse by priests and clergy of the Vatican, according to the National Catholic Reporter.

Here's the Duterte quote in it's original form:

“Catholic is a sordid religion. It is about time to show you its history. There were popes who sired a child and even had sex with his child, that was Pope Leo,” the President claimed.

This is why people need to read sources to verify that the claims being made are supported by the evidence. It's rubbish like this that justifies the fake news narrative.

ALDO_NOVA ago

"Pope Leo was sired and even had sex with his child."

that is exaclty what the OP title states

Htaed ago

He's still a pedophile.

IslamicStatePatriot ago

And Duarte is a crazed murder from the looks of things.

Htaed ago

Not even he would deny that.

SaneGoatiSwear ago

great response!

permit me to also share some censored information in this one day psa:

trust in truth

yeah why wouldn't the pope rape kids? the church leadership have been doing it for the entire history of the church.

also,

PSA to ALL USERS: the admins do nothing when law is broken on voat. the admins do nothing when the user agreement is broken on voat. the admins do nothing when reddit cancer is on voat (anymore). The user agreement is null and void. all bets are off. WINTER IS COMING. take the information as you will. you have been notified of information they have attempted to censor at great cost.

note: downvoating these Publice Service Announcements does not work. https://voat.co/v/whatever/1534074 https://voat.co/v/Parenting/1533925/7466568

bopper ago

Hey a moderator slammed me yesterday for breaking the law.

zoltan907 ago

Themindunleashed web site mangled the grammar of Duterte's quote, but the basic content seems to stay consistent across sources.

From themindunleashed: “Catholicism is a sordid religion. It is about time to show you its history. Pope Leo was sired and even had sex with his child.”

From RT, the source cited by themindunleashed: "'Catholic[ism] is a sordid religion. It is about time to show you its history,' he said, mentioning Pope Leo as someone 'sired and even had sex with his child.'"

From the Philippine Star, the source cited by RT: "'Catholic is a sordid religion. It is about time to show you its history. There were popes who sired a child and even had sex with his child, that was Pope Leo,' the President claimed."

So Duterte is talking about incest. Whether there was pedophilia involved in this particular case depends upon the age of the "child."

There were 13 popes named Leo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Leo

Duterte didn't specify which one he was talking about. Leo X has a reputation for corruption, but I haven't yet come across any source saying that Leo X was personally guilty of having committed incest. It's also possible Duterte got the name of the pope wrong, but the details of the story correct.

I don't know how comprehensive this list of sexually active popes is (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sexually_active_popes#Popes_alleged_to_be_sexually_active_during_pontificate)), but judging from this, it appears that John XII, Benedict IX, and Sixtus IV were among the most dissolute.

militant ago

Lot of misleading threads's titles these days... Most likely done on purpose.

remedy4reality ago

bro... I have no idea why you are parsing the statement. THE ENTIRE WORLD KNOWS THE VATICAN IS A CHILD RAPE FACTORY and it's paid out over $4 BILLION in hush money.

Baluga ago

Yes, and yet Pope Francis is making repeated public calls to end child abuse in the church, and promising swift action against anybody who covers it up. Do you think Francis is being two-faced with these proclamations?

Htaed ago

Same way a criminal tells others not to commit crime? It's so easy to do. What the pope says means nothing.

SlackeryTurnBull ago

What's he supposed to say now that it's all been uncovered?

Baluga ago

If you were watching, this was uncovered years ago, long before pizzagate. The previous popes said not much about it. When Francis came in, he said things have to change. Believe him or don't, but his speech is more favorable.

remedy4reality ago

TALK IS CHEAP

The_Invincible_Moose ago

I forgot the tl;dr for people who won't take the time to read. Thanks for the reminder. Here it goes:

tl;dr - The article claims that Philippine president Duterte called out the Vatican For pedophilia, but he didn't.

remedy4reality ago

yeah... I read it... you're completely splitting hairs to make a much, much, much smaller point.