Note: look at the mouth in the neutered noel, even the small teeth and girlish lips. Warning: disturbing content. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oicUO0sz08c . Here's a pic from the band's myspace(same smile.) https://myspace.com/apes/mixes/classic-my-photos-358362/photo/87829217. BIGGEST evidence that she's MA. She talks until 4:00( same voice modulator) goes off stage, gets on the keyboard, same clothes. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3QEC3S-Ao88 Compare this picture https://myspace.com/apes/mixes/classic-my-photos-358362/photo/87829208 (the Eyes) to 0:22-0:26. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=31rQiiqsv4A -0:26, obvious same brown eyes, large teethy smile.

No offense, but I really don't think ja is majestic ape. It seems like people just pulled that out of the air for some odd reason, in many vids, it's obvious that her body, teeth, and hands are very obviously a woman. I feel like people want to believe JA is MA so that women can't be evil or pedos, very strange and backwards. OTPROPHET already discussed everything else. Note: actually dig and don't believe strange logic, it just takes 10 min.

fking band knows a LOT. Fking band.

I wonder what would happen if they ever got their equipment stolen - as happens with so many other bands? What might be found on their drives and PCS.

You are correct, per your source (12/12/13 interview with Heavy Breathing) Amanda Kleinman is is the keyboardist.

According to that same interview, she is also the one who wears the mask and uses the voice modulator:

"Amanda, what’s with the mask?"

"AK: The mask started because Apes toured constantly, and I loved all of our singers, but we always felt like there was a missing human element. We wanted the singers to have more of a banter, more of an ease. And there were also so many nights where you’re in Epsilon, Michigan on a Tuesday night, and it’s pouring, and the only person in the bar is the barmaid… So it’s like this game with yourself: What am I going to do to make myself laugh and feel comfortable before I get on stage? And that ski mask started because I put it on and I stood at a mirror, and I was making scary faces to crack myself up to chill out.

There were situations in the early years where no one knew that I was a little short girl. I had dudes in Cincinnati respond to that [deep, effect-manipulated] voice saying, “I’ll take you out in the parking lot and kick your ass, fucker.” I love that part of the show, I really do."

You allege there are instances that the keyboardist and "Majestic Ape" appear on stage at the same time, but fail to provide evidence to support that claim.

Here is Kleinman in 2004 clearly identified as Majestic Ape, wearing a ski mask, with the caption:

When a band is introduced by Amanda as Majestic Ape as Lee, you know you're in for something special.

SLiMG Image http://www.theapes.com/04_10_euro/pics20.html https://archive.fo/GLTqx#selection-35.1-37.43

The caption says "Amanda as Majestic Ape as Lee". Remember that these people are artists and performers (as distasteful as that may be), and that Majestic Ape is a character for Kleinman's performances, usually before the band plays. In any case, they are going for shock value and creepiness, and "Lee" is Majestic Ape as a transvestite called Lee. It's all part of the creepy act, she is purposefully trying to sound like a creepy transexual when using the voice modulator and wearing the Majestic Ape mask and outfit. Here is a recording of that on their website of "Lee":

http://theapes.com/audio/Lee.mp3

A somewhat disturbing monologue completely improvised by Amanda Kleinman; inspired by Paul's new vocal pedal and its pitch shifter. http://theapes.com/audio.html

Here's another photo of Kleinman from the Apes website and she is specifically called "Majestic Ape" (from 2006). The caption reads:

Majestic Ape at the Black Cat in DC.

SLiMG Image http://www.theapes.com/pics/06-fall/pics.html?photo=4

Also this photo with the caption:

Majestic Ape on stage the Black Cat in DC.

SLiMG Image http://www.theapes.com/pics/06-fall/pics.html?photo=5

The members of Heavy Breathing (Kleinman, Schmid and Jackson) have a history of playing music together since they were fifteen. https://archive.fo/PRdlS

Sunday, January 13, 2008 Time to begin again posted by Majestic Ape at 1:07 PM I am going to start writing again. I am going to be writing often. Ape life never stops but I had been keeping an anonymous secret blog since early January and devoted quite a bit of time to it. It was a blog that I have been needing to write for quite some time. I had been wanting to incorporate elements of the secret blog into this one but I got the stop/block warning from my crew. So I went under.

Now, its not springtime. I usually associate springtime with feelings-- the only feelings that I allow myself. Not anymore. I am a female AND I play music. I can still have feelings. My feelings right now are that WE HAVE A GREAT FUCKING RECORD COMING OUT AND I AM EXCITED!

WE ARE GOING TO START TOURING AGAIN AND I AM EXCITED! My name is Amanda, and I play organ/keyboards for this band called Apes. We are based in Washington, DC and we have been together officially since 1999. I have been playing music with two of these fools since I was 15.

They have played in the bands Nightmare Assault (https://archive.fo/QA9id)) , The Apes, Midnight Kids, and Heavy Breathing.

At one time most of the band members when playing as The Apes where wearing ski masks as shown in the photo archive here:

• http://www.theapes.com/pics3.html
• http://www.theapes.com/04_10_euro/pics20.html
• http://www.theapes.com/us_tour_mar_2002/pics13.html
• http://www.theapes.com/europe_mar_2002/pics10.html
• http://www.theapes.com/pics/05-april/pics16.html

Here are a couple of entries from The Apes 2007 tour diary, authored by Majestic Ape: http://blog.theapes.com/labels/tour.html

http://blog.theapes.com/2007/03/spring-mini-tour-2007-sxsw.html

I’m psyched. It feels like an eternity since our last show. I put on the ski masks, fetch some bottled waters from the bar, and warm up the crowd with a voice-altered comedy.

http://blog.theapes.com/home/blog/public_html/2005_07_01_archive.html

I turn around in my sunglasses and ski mask. I smile at the music company exec. I smile big.

"You need to stand out like that!" he says excitedly and points to me. Whoa. I was hoping to scare him. Oops. Wrong reaction.

Here Kleinman talks about wearing the ski mask and wandering around alone at night: https://archive.fo/4UWPZ

Jackie Majik and I are jamming most evenings and after dark, I wander the city alone. While I wander, I meet strange and interesting characters that sometimes provide interesting conversation and occasionally add wisdom to otherwise uniwse days. There is one particular person that I met this week that stands out. This is a person that I may meet again and if there are things worth sharing, I may mention them again in this forum.

I met him on the Calvert Street Bridge when I was wandering late Tuesday night and he stopped me because I was wearing a red ski mask. Usually I wear the ski mask so people won't talk to me but I guess he was intrigued. I noticed him because of his....well...it really doesn't matter...at this point I'd rather keep his physical deformities out of the discussion....

6th period bell just rang, I have to stop hiding in the music supply closet...more to come..

https://archive.fo/NF5Uw

Thursday in Austin posted by Majestic Ape at 11:53 PM

After clean-up, it’s our turn. I have pondering topics for the pre-show chat. What I planned was lost immediately. For some reason, I tell a horrible pedophile joke.

Here you can see all the references she makes to "costume" in the Apes tour diary:

SLiMG Image https://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3Atheapes.com+costume&t=ffab&atb=v41-2&ia=web

From their press page: http://www.theapes.com/press.html

MOJO -- "The Apes are one of the wildest acts on today's underground rock circuit, combining baroque, Deep Purple-esque keyboard flurries (courtesy of mask-wearing organist Amanda Kleinman) with aggressive Fun House rhythms (bassist Erick Jackson and drummer Jeff Schmid are as primal as the band's name suggests)....Inevitably, some of the impact is lost on disc, but this third LP does feature their catchiest songs to date." (2005)

Amanda Kleinman is vulnerable for charges. She's the weak link hence these shills coming out of the woodwork to obfuscate what is known. Ms. Kleinman works with children and is open to real charges being leveled against her for her actions/words. http://www.popmatters.com/review/apes-oddeyesee/

they BOTH play the ape. Some clips it's her, some it's him. They look different, sound different etc.

Amen.

Yet you keep ignoring the videos and images where Majestic Ape is onstage simultaneously with Amanda Kleinman.

And this explains why you abruptly end the conversation, because you have nothing to explain that away with. It just doesn't fit your narrative so you ignore it.

I mean, just looking at the mouth of the face beneath the ski mask and comparing it to the face of Kleinman would shut down what you're alleging, but if you haven't read what I posted or acknowledged the two being onstage together at points, you're probably not likely to investigate enough to analyze both faces.

Even with the information you've provided, all you are able to say is the BAND tells people Kleinman is Majestic Ape, but we aren't exactly dealing with angelic, honest souls here...

This is probably the 12th thread I've read about this. I decided long ago that the costume is likely shared by Alefantis and Kleinman.

I'm not confusing things. I'm saying that it's untrue that it's Amanda Kleinman, seeing as Majestic Ape has been onstage simultaneously with Amanda Kleinman, which I've also posted, so it simply cannot be Amanda Kleinman -- and most of us agree that it is in no way a woman, rather a man in drag, so regardless of what the band chose to tell the SFist website (maybe misleading Majestic's identity intentionally -- read through the other comments, this could be because multiple people play the role, but it's not Amanda - at least not in the live footage we've seen).

Also you could consider SFist assumed Majestic Ape was Kleinman and this is not accurate information on their part. All signs (other than this one line on a website you're showing me which I have already seen) point to this not being her.

By alleging MA is Amanda, when YouTube still has live footage wherein both MA and Amanda are next to each other, it's only you who is confusing things and unwilling to accept this new information. That's the mentality and approach that hurts the investigation. I'm a mod here, and take this whole story very seriously - trust I'm not confusing things.

What you are saying is not entirely true. Amanda Kleinman was in the band The Apes, yes, but she is the keyboard player in Heavy Breathing, and isn't the red-masked Majestic Ape, at least not at the times they've both been in the same room.

You're wrong, and it seems you didn't read any of my post or go to the links I've provided that prove this.

You seem to be the one confused here, no offense.

Did you read my post or did you just blindly comment? Because I definitely covered Heavy Breathing and who they are, and I definitely said they were 3/4 of The Apes, so why you're responding with this info is beyond me -- but either way, Amanda is NOT "Majestic Ape". She is the keyboardist of the band.

I've seen pics where it is a girl, and pics where it is Alefantis for certain. He has a distinctive mouth and smile, theres a couple pics where its clearly him, but then I've seen some where its not him.

That's what I'm thinking. Even if you're using downvoting as a disagree button, most people here legitimately investigating the topic would have addressed what it was exactly they disagreed with...

Look at the video The Neutered Noel (if you can stomach it) it's here https://voat.co/v/pizzagate/1457070. Also you can look up threads here about it. Close ups of MA in at least this video clearly show a differnt set of lips under the mask than when Alefantis appears in a red mask (which he most certainly does in at least some photos) His wide smirk is unmistakable, A Kleinman's appearance for example in the Noel video close up shows lips that are clearly different- more feminie, a clear dip in the middle of the top lip, even a touch of lip gloss.

A Kleinman was on the road and was in some of these videos - she provides plausable denial as a "beard" to Alefantis who can deny ever donning the mask. My theory is that he is the impresario behind the video productions and some of the music, AK is just a performer and beard. She may have been raised in mind control situations, and she at times refers to herself as "Puppet".

I agree I never thought it was her. Always seemed distinctively male. Looks like alifantis to me