You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

Epictetus_Hierapolis ago

I have an mg42, and half of the kubel it will be mounted on. https://files.catbox.moe/29mxy4.jpg

clamhurt_legbeard ago

no

fucking

waaaaaay

thats fucking awesome

ok so this is an excellent opportunity

what are your thoughts on comparing the mg42 and the 240

Epictetus_Hierapolis ago

Clearing the feed tray, loading, and remediation feed failures is virtually identical. Operating the weapon does not feel the same at all though due to the different rates of fire and weight distribution. One thing I really noticed was the constant failures of the 240s, almost always eating a link. The comments were always 'because Marines, we get old broken shit', but I rarely had failures on the 34s and 42s that I ran belts of blanks through and they were 70 years old.

clamhurt_legbeard ago

ive heard of many complaints from the second generation of guys using m60s

the m60 is very lightly constructed and wears

if you get a worn one it gives a bunch of headaches

meanwhile the seals prefer the m60 over the 240 because they can afford to maintain it so much better

i wonder if the 240s were getting worn out

assuming an excellent condition example of each

which was better with fire rate and weigt distribution in your experience

Epictetus_Hierapolis ago

Really depends. Obviously I'm using the 42 in a quasi tactical situation, and it really looses all suppressive ability when you factor in the blanks and the fact that fat American reenactors are impervious to anything us SS throw at them. Another limiting factor is that I am not dealing with a huge amount of recoil with the 34 or 42, and blanks weigh a lot less.

In ideal situations, for their respective time periods, all other factors theoretically equal, I would take the 240. Not because it is a better gun, but strictly due to logistics.

The 42 is a cleaner weapon, is easier and more manageable to carry, has less upward stray, a much higher volume of fire, and is scary as hell to be downrange of (I've pulled pits downrange of one, they are fucking terrifying. A 240 or 249 is like a hornets nest of buzzing and snapping, the 42 is indescribable in ferocity). The drawback, and I see it as a major drawback, is the limitations in the amount of ammo a fire team can carry in comparison to the rate of fire. That may entirely be doctrine based, as I've always reenacted with other vets of Iraq and Afghanistan, so it is entirely possible that our employment of the 42 is completely out of practice with how the heer or SS would have used it. While we do try to conduct squad operations in a historical manner, there are implicit biases due to our years of knowing we had quick resupply. Comparably at least.

We can keep 2000 rds of ammo spread out between the squad, panzer, and half track, but even in the very limited scale of a reenactment we burn through on hand ammo within seconds. It's fairly difficult to get a tracked vehicle to stop and let you get supplies without a squad radio.

This leaves the 42 limited to short bursts of high intensity fire and maneuver. Once riflemen are withing effective range, it is usually up to them to engage and destroy. With the 240, you can pump rounds downrange and still have some to spare for consolidation and security within the same amount of time.

None of that, however, can hide the massive boner you get firing a 34 or 42 at a group of American reenactors.

clamhurt_legbeard ago

'I've pulled pits downrange of one, they are fucking terrifying.

hoooly fuck lol

i bet thats quite an experience

It's fairly difficult to get a tracked vehicle to stop and let you get supplies without a squad radio.

a very amusing comparison of the practical advantages of modern technology

boner

hahaha

excellent

big thanks for sharing your detailed experiences

this is great

Epictetus_Hierapolis ago

When you finally get around to the scar(because it had better be a gun clammy likes), give me a heads up so I can clean off all the white paint pen writing on it.

clamhurt_legbeard ago

fuck yes

i havent forgotten

now that i did the ar i need to do the attempted improvements

you promised pictures and video heh heh