You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

modsrcuntz ago

So what are truely the best email and search engines...any?

alele-opathic ago

This is the exact question which can't have any trustworthy answer. Although I expound on why here, the gist is that you have no way of discerning genuine replies from shill answers. Additionally, shills target these questions because they directly impact consumer decision making, meaning there is a very high likelihood noise will exceed signal in a question like that.

Just set aside 3 or 4 hours this upcoming weekend, and put the topic to rest for yourself.

modsrcuntz ago

Is signal a good app or is that not what we have been told either?

alele-opathic ago

I hadn't heard of Signal before you mentioned it, but decided to look into it. Here's what I found.

  • The front page is a substance-less advert heavy on rhetoric and testimonial -> minor suspicion
  • The first recommendation is by spook Edward Snowden, from the massive limited hangout that drove everyone into DDG in the first place. You should look more into his background if you are curious why this is a -> major suspicion
  • The owner, Moxie Marlinspike is really (((Moxie Rosenfield))). This will either be of major suspicion to you, or none at all. For me, it is of -> major suspicion
  • Supposedly they are entirely financed by 'charitable donations' and grants, which are funneled through foundations (the most common way money is laundered into these new ops) -> minor suspicion
  • The foundation supposedly started for Signal is never disclosed (Signal Foundation), and no information on it is given/can be found around the web -> minor suspicion
  • The IRS nonprofit search (all non-profit records are public records) returns 3 signal foundations. I searched the three respective states' business license registries and all are long dead (i.e. it doesn't exist) -> major suspicion

To me, this WAY fails the smell test. This ignores a number of other circumstantial problems with Signal.

1F4A9 ago

  • Design choices that are anti-anonimity. There is no good reason for an app like Signal to require that you register with your phone number, other than that is what it's meta-data collecting financiers want -> major suspicion
  • Receives financing from US goverment -> major suspicion
  • It's company and foundation are founded under American jurisdiction. That's like starting a platform comitted to free speech in North Korea. If you're serious about privacy you don't primarily operate from a country that is known for extensive data collection programs and a legal obligation to cooperate and shut up about it -> major suspicion
  • Initially Signal refused to provide an APK, basically encouraging you to use the Google Play store -> minor suspicion