Personally, I think it should be based on number of comments, rather than CCP (although, I suppose this could be an issue too, if the sub is totally dead or like /v/sports, as you said) if we're to have a rule like this. In many larger subs you could make a comment, and if the post is highly upvoated, get the 300 CCP from that single comment - whereas someone else might make 100 comments and still not be there. I guess it depends on what the 300 CCP rule is intended for, though (i.e. is it to show activity/interest in the sub?).
Also, there could be a rule that supersedes this. Say, something like 1k CCP and 500 comments globally. Just something to show the requester is active, is what I'm getting at.
Anyway, those are just my thoughts on the matter. We'll see how it all works out :)
view the rest of the comments →
AmyAcker ago
Personally, I think it should be based on number of comments, rather than CCP (although, I suppose this could be an issue too, if the sub is totally dead or like /v/sports, as you said) if we're to have a rule like this. In many larger subs you could make a comment, and if the post is highly upvoated, get the 300 CCP from that single comment - whereas someone else might make 100 comments and still not be there. I guess it depends on what the 300 CCP rule is intended for, though (i.e. is it to show activity/interest in the sub?).
Also, there could be a rule that supersedes this. Say, something like 1k CCP and 500 comments globally. Just something to show the requester is active, is what I'm getting at.
Anyway, those are just my thoughts on the matter. We'll see how it all works out :)