You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

Pizzalawyer ago

I guess this molester's urges were just too strong. Such persons do not make good parents to begin with and they should just be castrated, and I am dead serious.

Factfinder2 ago

There is debate about the efficacy of castration or any other preventive measure, and because of this, there should be no second chances for child rapists imo.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/wellness/1992/03/17/does-castration-stop-sex-crimes/34bf63ee-840c-41e4-9c5f-5ac1bcf95b15/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.536ac0ae6f3b

"Rape crisis workers say that violence, not sex, is the real problem, which castration fails to address. "This misfocuses the issue and feeds into the myths about rape," said Denise Snyder, executive director of the D.C. Rape Crisis Center. "Sexual assault is a crime of violence and aggression . . . not the product of an uncontrollable sex drive."

The problem is often in the brain, not the testicles, said Barbara K. Schwartz, director of the Sex Offender Treatment Program at Twin Rivers Correctional Center in Monroe, Wash. A rapist who has been castrated "could still be a phenomenal danger. He can go out and, instead of raping people, he can assault them with broom handles or bottles or beat them up or kill them." "

Pizzalawyer ago

you are right about the literature but there you are dealing with chemical castration which may not be as effective as people think. Ancient cultures employed actual removal of the testicles to create eunuchs to serve and guard harems.

Gelded horses and nuetered dogs are for the most part quite neutral sexually, only occasionally aroused..

I agree that rape of an adult peer is based in large part on violence and power but I am not convinced as to.children. Men, and its mostly men , aren't commiting a violent act when watching child pornography. Those with violent urges will select violent pornography. The news is filled with men murdering children devoid of any sex. So I think we still have a long ways to go to understanding all of this but I favor drastic measures (other than murder!) until we know more. Thanks for the discussion.

septimasexta ago

"Men, and its mostly men , aren't commiting a violent act when watching child pornography." You have just exposed yourself, PEDO-PIZZA-LAWYER. No wonder this discussion has you sweating...

Factfinder2 ago

From the article:

"In Denmark in the late 1950s and early 1960s sex offenders were permitted to choose prison or surgical castration. Research on 900 castrated sex offenders showed that the rate of repeat offenses was low, about 5 percent."

Here they are talking about surgical castration. My point is that even a "low" 5% rate of reoffending is too much. So is anything above zero. The assault of even one child by a person who has previously been identified as an offender is simply not acceptable IMO.

Pizzalawyer ago

Thanks for that info.. Those are better results than I would have expected. But what can we do? A life sentence in a prison to insure 0% recidivism? Bill Clinton got a bill.passed that called for 3 strikes, ie felonies, then a life sentence which in the case of a child molester could very well turn into a death sentence.

Factfinder2 ago

Life in captivity is appropriate IMO. You can be assured that child rapists are keenly aware of what their lives in prison would be like if caught and convicted, but they still make the decision to rape.

I ask you, how is it appropriate to release a KNOWN predator with ANY potential to reoffend into a society full of innocent children?

How many children do you think it would be okay to put at risk in order to ensure that a convicted child rapist doesn't get hurt in prison?

I believe you don't really want to put any children at risk, but I urge you to think about this in real world terms. When these creeps are released from prison, children are at risk. It is a fact.

We need to take off the rose-colored glasses and adjust penalties to match crimes. A child's entire life is stolen when he or she is raped--their whole life--and they didn't get to choose whether or not they wanted to have their lives ruined.