You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

Are_we__sure ago

What does it mean to randomly die?

Why do find it surprising her dog did not die?

You're implying her hiking partner did something suspicious?

Oh_Well_ian ago

You would make the worst cop in the world.

Actually, you would fit right in as head of DC Police.

Are_we_sure ago

Because I would refuse to make up crimes left and right? Because I would refuse to screenwrite pre-made conspiracies in my head instead of letting the evidence dictate my conclusions?

She did not randomly die of heat stroke.

She DID go hiking in that canyon on a hot day with her friend. She DID feel unwell and turned back. Her friend continued on. (This point was incorrectly reported in the first news reports like the DailyMail report above.) The LA Times story has this correction on it.

FOR THE RECORD: Sally Menke obituary: The obituary of film editor Sally Menke in the Sept. 29 LATExtra section said Menke, who was found dead after she went hiking in Griffith Park, had continued on the hike while her walking companion turned back. Police said Wednesday that Menke had cut short the hike and that the other walker had continued. In addition, the article incorrectly said that Menke's dog was a yellow Labrador retriever. It was a black Labrador. —

So rather than writing a screenplay in our heads, let's look at the known facts as stated here https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/oscar-nominated-editor-56-found-28445 and here http://articles.latimes.com/2010/sep/29/local/la-me-sally-menke-20100929

*9AM Menke and a friend go for a hike with her dog. *About 45 minutes later Menke says she feels dizzy and said she was going to go back to her car *Her friend continued on. *About 15 minutes after the two split up, Menke is seen alone by another hikre. She appeared disoriented but declined any help, *10:15 am she called her husband on her cell phone *She is not seen again *at 4PM her friends label her missing *Her locked car is found where she left it *At 2am her body is found at the body of a ravine *Her dog is standing next to her and is severely dehydrated. *There's no evidence of foul play *Her death is later determined to be heat related. *Menke had a history of seizures

This is not a random death from hyperthermia. This is a very specific set of facts.

Now what should a good cop do with this set of facts?

millennial_vulcan ago

How much are the pedos paying you for your retard posts?

Are_we_sure ago

Wow. You can't deal with the facts can you? You come up with a theory of foul play. I lay out all the facts for why foul play is very unlikely and you refuse to engage the argument, you just make up lies about me.

PedoStomper ago

You are the kind of person who thinks that "hits" and assassinations don't even exist. Your opinion means nothing, because you are nothing. No one here gives a shit about anything you say, yet you just keep on trying. Sounds like someone is getting paid for his time, or why else would you keep coming here?

millennial_vulcan ago

Sssh Quentin - go take your meds. And try not to rape anyone today.