They are more a function of your subjective opinion which has no place in moderation.

.

3: Clarity: All titles must adequately describe post content and must establish direct relevance to pizzagate. EACH link in your post must include a description of content and how the link relates to the post (except when markup is used to embed links in the specific text they support).

Very far from subjective. This post does not meet this standard.

This is something that the votes should have decided.

Sure, I have no issues with that - for posts that hold to the rules which this one doesn't.

What about this post gives it a pass on rule 3?