Below is the reply I sent to @Vindicator who asked the same question:
The all caps shouty title is enough to ask for an edit to the title.
Much of the content looks like copy paste. Even with a concerted effort it's hard to understand what the poster is on about.
If posters aren't willing to at least format things marginally better and add a simple summary at the top to help readers understand the premise we shouldn't be forced to lower standards to the point that spam garbage becomes acceptable.
This post does look like a solid bit of speculative info that's worth of discussion - but in the form it is currently presented it's better posted to whatever, and then through community discussion OP could easily gain a handle on what would make sense for a main post.
The poster asking for help in the post itself should be an indicator this is more suitable to a whatever post in order to crowd source some editing and expansive writing.
While good at a shallow evaluation, this is the kind of content that turns away people looking for core, solid information that then can apply in their lives to contribute to solving the problem.
I would have deleted the post and asked for heavy editing myself.
view the rest of the comments →
VictorSteinerDavion ago
Why?
Below is the reply I sent to @Vindicator who asked the same question:
The all caps shouty title is enough to ask for an edit to the title.
Much of the content looks like copy paste. Even with a concerted effort it's hard to understand what the poster is on about.
If posters aren't willing to at least format things marginally better and add a simple summary at the top to help readers understand the premise we shouldn't be forced to lower standards to the point that spam garbage becomes acceptable.
This post does look like a solid bit of speculative info that's worth of discussion - but in the form it is currently presented it's better posted to whatever, and then through community discussion OP could easily gain a handle on what would make sense for a main post. The poster asking for help in the post itself should be an indicator this is more suitable to a whatever post in order to crowd source some editing and expansive writing.
While good at a shallow evaluation, this is the kind of content that turns away people looking for core, solid information that then can apply in their lives to contribute to solving the problem.
I would have deleted the post and asked for heavy editing myself.