You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

daemonaux ago

It's nice. As /u/Nurdoidz said, black outline is problematic. It is neither here nor there. I would make it thinner.

Now be smart and replace upvote/downvote arrows with the one from the logo. It'll tie the room together.

EDIT: Something...

Atko ago

Umm... @nurdoidz designed those arrows :) But I agree, either logo or the arrows should be adjusted so they look the same.

Nurdoidz ago

I tried my hand at recreating the logo that fits exactly with the rest of the site's theme.

  • This is the full-sized logo.
  • This is the logo scaled down to front page width.
  • This is what it looks like on the front page.
  • This is a fun timelapse I made of the process creating the raster-based logo (before I created the vector-based).

The concept of this logo is the version similar to Mr. O'Keefe's but using the official Minity color pallet. Here is the source SVG source link: Voat-logo.svg (9 KiB).

Polling @SchrodingersCatPics, @DanielFlamino for thoughts.


Edit 1: I darkened the outlines of the 'o' and 't', reuploaded, and updated the link. The legacy logo is still available here. Updated Paint.NET source link. Updated comment formatting.


Edit 2: I created a vector-based image of the logo. Updated SVG source link. Updated logo and front page preview image link. Updated comment body to reflect the latest version.

squiremarcus ago

holy shit they used your logo, i DO like it better btw

Atko ago

Since @SchrodingersCatPics seems to be away, I'll take down this version (which I amateurishly digitalized from a rough sketch made by @SchrodingersCatPics) and replace it with your version. If @SchrodingersCatPics comes up with another solution and people like it, I'll be happy to make the switch but I have a feeling he will like your version too :)

SchrodingersCatPics ago

Oh wow! I love this new version! It's nice and soft and the rounded edges definitely make it pleasant to look at! Great work, /u/Nurdoidz! I totally approve; this is a great logo!

Nurdoidz ago

Wow, I'm glad you like it! :-)

SchrodingersCatPics ago

I love it! It seems much more approachable and friendly, if you will, and I like the way the triangles have a distinct top and bottom now, that better mimics the upvote and downvote arrows!

Nurdoidz ago

Awesome! I almost forgot about it, to be honest. :-P Wonder when he'll be back.

Atko ago

Wow, you're on fire again! :) Thanks for giving it a go. I like it a lot. We will need a vector version though if we are to make it official.

@SchrodingersCatPics is probably also working on his own v2 so I suggest we wait for his input as well.

Nurdoidz ago

Well, I learned a whole new program for vector-based images and recreated the logo in a vector-based format:

I am not sure why I didn't learn this program before because, man, it scales easier, edits better, and I don't have to manually design the anti-aliasing. Looks like I have another tool on my design toolbelt! :-)

Anyway, I'd love to see what @SchrodingersCatPics comes up with, though. I will be waiting patiently!

Polling @DanielFlamino as well.

Atko ago

Now we're talking! I think it looks great. Good job on learning to create vector graphics so fast btw!

Nurdoidz ago

Ah, yes, of course. There's no need to rush it. I am excited to see what he comes up with!

daemonaux ago

Ooops. :)

Atko ago

Haha :p