You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

Nurdoidz ago

If only praises are considered, then I don't think there is a point in making a comment in the first place. Even with that understood, I am going to make a critique anyway. I like the logo a lot. It's clever in the fact that it uses the arrows as the letters and even includes the color scheme of the site.

There is one detail that makes it awkward for me, though, and it's the outline. Compared to the rest of the site, the outline is too pronounced: thick and dark and stands out too much. It makes the rest of the site washed out by contrast and is the reason I avoided dark outlines in the rest of the design.

If the outline was thinner and lighter, it would be the perfect logo for the site. However, if the outlines stay, the designer inside of me would say that the rest of the site would need to be designed to reflect the new style.


Edit: I made an attempt at a minity-style logo based off of Mr. O'Keefe's logo. Here is the comment thread.

Gamerdog6482 ago

It looks perfectly fine with the dark theme, which I have a suspicion is what it was designed in mind for.

Nurdoidz ago

Well, if you want to speculate, I can argue that it was actually designed for the light theme, since the dark theme has a completely different color pallet. Both the blue and violet shade in the logo match the light voting arrows almost exactly. White is also an almost non-existent color in the dark theme.

The logo looks better in the dark theme because the outline doesn't stand out as much.