You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

PiercingAjarDolphin ago

I'm glad there is a definite push here to punish those that censor other users. I also think there has to be something done with downvoats since people are starting to use those again as disagreement buttons. That's what led to Reddits demise and what's going to kill this place if we don't watch out for it. I'll be the first one to admit that it's hard to get over that Reddit knee-jerk reaction to downvote content you don't agree with, but I think that if we all make a conscious effort, we can improve the signal to noise ratio on this site.

Remember, downvoating is a soft censorship tool, try and use it to improve the discussion, not to make the thread an echo chamber.

thuvia_1 ago

I'm glad there is a definite push here to punish those that censor other users.

removing @she as a mod would be punishment, taking the subverse off /v/all is not punishment. @she can act however s/he wants in that sub as a mod, still. i'm not advocating his/her removal, but i'm kind of confused by all the 'thank yous' and 'well dones'. don't get me wrong, i'm glad to see @atko stepping forward and taking an active role in managing the site. i just wonder, ultimately, what good removing a sub from the front page will do when the moderation is so clearly the problem.

PiercingAjarDolphin ago

It's because that becoming a default sub means you're doing something the whole community benefits from. You know, it's stuff everyone except a small subset of people can engage in and enjoy. If Akto then makes AskVoat2 the default sub, everyone will flock there instead. But if they act up in the same way, even with a slant towards SJWs, I'd say that Akto should again take that previlege from them as well.

Taking subs away from moderators for enforcing a slanted view isn't going to fix this place, that'll just turn it into Reddit 2.0. Or you know, they could just start banning them like Reddit does. Zero difference in the end.