I can't stand by and watch stuff like this happen around here. I will not support subverses (by featuring them or making them defaults) with moderators who impose questionable rules such as "your post has to end with a questionmark". Moderators need to calm their tits and focus on nurturing and growing their communities. Rules can always be bent and what better time to bend the rules then now, while Voat is still growing and under development?
I am thankful for moderators who help keep Voat spam-free and I respect your work. I really do. I started working on automoderator for comments and submissions and your job will be made much easier when this is implemented, but for the time being, moderators need to relax and focus on removing spam and eventual illegal content. If I submit a new post and it gains some traction (hundreds of comments, views and upvoats), and my post gets removed because I broke a rule by forgetting to include a question mark in my submission title... well, I would be pissed. People take removal of their comments and submissions very seriously and moderators must think twice before removing stuff if they want to avoid offending users. Voat has a ranking process where time acts as gravity and older posts will eventually fall off the frontpage. Voat also has automatic public moderation logs and everything you remove will still be visible in these modlogs and your actions may be questioned by the community, just like what happened yesterday.
This action can be reverted if /askvoat mods can convince us that the issue has been dealt with or if some other, less restrictive community takes over.
view the rest of the comments →
goofybud16 ago
As the moderator of /v/halflife, I agree, the moderator serves the community.
However, I don't know that allowing some sort of voting system would be the right way to do it. (This is the way I have seen sugguested)
I try not to remove any post unless it breaks the rules. I have removed one post for being spammy and breaking the rules.
I have put a lot of effort into designing /v/halflife, doing the CSS for /v/halflife, images for /v/halflife, etc. If someone disagreed with one of my opinions [unrelated to moderating], got their friends to be active in the subreddit so that they can sway the voat, then voat themselves in, I would be really pissed. I had done nothing wrong, but the other person got in simply because they have several friends.
With the voat moderators in/out setup, it would be very easy for SRS/SJW people to come in, take over a bunch of subreddits, shut them down, and effectively kill Voat.
leery ago
Now that you've shown what shouldn't be done, remember what issues the proposal of a voting system was proposed to solve, and propose a better way to solve it!
Broc_Lia ago
Migrations. End of.