You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

leixiaotie ago

Really, what I mean is in this context. If she had family, then she no longer has it, because it's already in the past! If she has, then it still going on to present date.

codyave ago

i said had in the sense that "[person] had a family" in the sense that now that [person] is dead, they no longer have a family because...dead people can't have families.

You do raise an interesting point about semantics I hadn't considered. Hmmm....

leixiaotie ago

Nah forget it, I'm confused myself XD