You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

TheKillerRabbit ago

We need to institute a system where the subscribers can elect/kick out mods through voting. Subs turn to shit when mods are allowed to go unchecked for their actions. Thank you Atko for showing us that you don't take kindly to mod abuse.

neonneophyte ago

I think this is better. I have always had the opinion that a dictatorship could be better than any democracy, if the right person was the dictator. Sounds terrible but it is true IMO.

I think Atko is that right dictator.

tpdplsio ago

I think for a site like this, where the whole thing can come crashing down and the owners/employees could have their lives fucked over what the users do, it's necessary to have a benevolent dictator. No user is going to take the fall for the serious shit that could happen. Whether that is Atko/Puttitout or a board of directors or some other body, it's necessary to have someone in charge that has something at stake.

TheKillerRabbit ago

Remember Alex Ohanian? How he fought against SOPA and how everyone used to love the guy back when reddit was a new thing? Remember how he said that reddit was a free speech haven? Remember all the things he has done recently? Atko is human; humans tend to let power get into their heads. I'm certain that Atko will be corrupted by the power he wields managing a site like voat. May take years, but he will be corrupted.

dis_is_my_account ago

I'm not so sure Atko is really for free speech in the first place. It seems like he adopted those ideals earlier on and didn't have a chance to go any other way because of what the backlash would be from an entire userbase who did believe in those ideals and came here for them. I think he may just be going with the majority alot of the time.

pitenius ago

Counter-example. Kind of a dick, but incorruptible.

InnocentBystander ago

There are examples of benevolent dictatorships working quite well when a non-authorian type is put in charge. Linus Torvalds is probably the best example. He has never been corrupted.

Linux would not exist if he had tried to do it democratically.

When a person seeks power, they become corrupt (or start out corrupt). But when a person seeks a goal, and power comes as a bonus, it's a different situation. Many people are good in power positions. But people who are good with power rarely seek it. Thrust them into the position and results can often be good.

tpdplsio ago

Give him a chance to fail first. You can always just leave if things go bad. Atko/Puttitout have everything to lose here.

Plus Reddit was different because it was bought out so quickly. The founders were kept around but they ultimately had no control over the business. Even then it took almost a decade for it to really turn to shit.

neonneophyte ago

So we string him up and look for our next benevolent ruler.

Spotddawg ago

Don't let your pitchforks get rusty.