This is almost exactly what I took from the debate. I was surprised at Amalek's level headed approach. I agree with amalek that you can't use the bible as evidence in an argument. I think SirMegahhikitha would have done better to pursue the argument that no modern state is legitimate as it would have made the debate a bit more interesting.
view the rest of the comments →
Reddiggoat ago
Let me sum up the debate for those late to the party.
Amalek - Why should the Jews have Israel?
SarMegahhikkitha - Because god said so, it's in the bible. Look at all this "proof" god exists.
Amalek - WTF dude, do you have any real arguments?
SarMegahhikkitha - No we are the chosen ones because god said so.
Amalek - Fuck this shit I'm out.
Toska ago
This is almost exactly what I took from the debate. I was surprised at Amalek's level headed approach. I agree with amalek that you can't use the bible as evidence in an argument. I think SirMegahhikitha would have done better to pursue the argument that no modern state is legitimate as it would have made the debate a bit more interesting.